Tether (USDT) Investment Analysis – A Comprehensive Report

Page 3

‍

In the EU, new regulations are directly affecting Tether. The EU’s MiCA (Markets in Crypto-Assets) framework, which begins implementation in 2024-2025, will require stablecoin issuers to obtain licenses to operate in Europe. As of Jan 2025, Tether was noticeably not on the list of MiCA-approved stablecoin issuers (10 stablecoin issuers approved under EU’s MiCA — Tether is left out). Exchanges have started delisting USDT for EU customers ahead of MiCA’s deadline because Tether did not yet comply with the stringent requirements (10 stablecoin issuers approved under EU’s MiCA — Tether is left out). This means European users may be cut off from USDT (or at least face restrictions), which could shrink Tether’s market or push volume to less regulated regions. Tether has criticized these actions as “rushed” and expressed intent to comply in time (10 stablecoin issuers approved under EU’s MiCA — Tether is left out), but the episode highlights regulatory risk: if major jurisdictions lock out USDT, its global usage could fragment. Other countries like Canada have also indirectly restricted Tether – Canadian regulators in 2021 approved certain stablecoins (like USDC) for exchanges but excluded USDT, likely due to transparency concerns. Asia has been more permissive (Tether is heavily used in Asia), though any change in stance by jurisdictions like Hong Kong, Singapore, or offshore havens could impact it.

Regulators also worry about systemic risk and run scenarios. Stablecoins connect crypto markets to traditional finance (since reserves are in banks and assets). The Bank of International Settlements (BIS) warned that widespread stablecoin use in emerging markets could amplify financial risk, calling the benefits “illusory” (Stablecoin Tether gets boost as dollar alternative in emerging markets, CEO says | Reuters). U.S. regulators have cautioned banks that stablecoin reserves can see rapid outflows in stress situations (Tether's $100 billion stokes stablecoin stability concerns | Reuters). For example, if crypto markets panic and everyone redeems USDT at once, Tether would need to liquidate reserves quickly; such fire-sales of assets (Treasuries, etc.) could have ripple effects in traditional markets. This scenario also ties into liquidity risk – even though Tether’s assets are generally high-quality now, liquidating tens of billions on short notice could still be disruptive. Tether’s size (>$100B) means it’s firmly on regulators’ radar as a potential point of failure. Any regulatory action – be it enforcement, new laws, or restrictions on banks dealing with Tether – could pose a significant challenge. The extreme case would be if governments decided to ban or severely curtail Tether usage due to money laundering or systemic risk concerns. Tether has tried to proactively cooperate with law enforcement (they have frozen over $1 billion in illicit assets when requested by authorities to combat crime) (Tether freezes $5.2M in USDT linked to phishing scams), but paradoxically this ability to freeze addresses also highlights its centralized control, which some regulators see as necessary, while some crypto purists see as a drawback.

Counterparty and Custodial Risks: Tether’s model relies on trust in a few critical counterparties: its banks/custodians and its own management. Unlike a decentralized stablecoin, USDT holders rely on Tether Ltd. to manage reserves properly. That introduces operational risks – e.g., if Tether’s primary bank (or custodian) holding reserves were to fail or lose access to funds, it could jeopardize redeemability. There have been instances historically where Tether had funds seized or frozen (the Crypto Capital incident in 2018 where hundreds of millions were lost, leading to the Bitfinex loan situation). Tether now likely diversifies banking relationships, but it’s not public exactly where reserves are held. If any banking partner got into trouble or was subject to sanctions, Tether might temporarily be unable to access reserve funds. Another aspect is redemption logistics: officially, authorized users (typically large traders or institutions) can redeem USDT directly with Tether for $1 (with a minimum amount and KYC requirements). If, for some reason, Tether halted redemptions (due to a bank issue or regulatory order), the peg could break in the secondary market. In May 2022, during the Terra-UST crisis, Tether did process ~$10B of redemptions in a week, proving significant ability to meet withdrawals (Tether says it has completely eliminated commercial paper from reserves | Reuters), though USDT’s market price did dip to ~$0.97 briefly on some exchanges amidst the panic. So far, Tether has managed to restore confidence each time, but the risk of a “bank run” is inherent to any stablecoin: if a critical mass of users doubt the backing, they will rush to redeem or sell, which can strain the system.

Additionally, technology and security risks exist. Tether is issued on multiple blockchains, meaning it relies on the security of those underlying networks. If there were a hack or exploit in the smart contract bridges, or a major blockchain (like Ethereum or Tron) had a technical failure affecting tokens, that could create confusion or losses. Tether has in the past had to coordinate token swaps or freezes when exchanges were hacked (freezing stolen USDT to prevent thief from moving it). While that shows responsive risk management, it also highlights a central point of control – Tether can freeze or even destroy USDT tokens (and reissue replacements) if needed. For ordinary holders, this is usually not a concern unless you unknowingly receive tainted funds from illicit sources, but it’s a centralization aspect to be aware of.

Market and Black Swan Risks: By holding USDT, investors assume not only the credit risk of Tether but also some systemic crypto-market risk. A hypothetical black swan event for Tether could be a scenario where, for instance, a sudden regulatory ban happens simultaneously with a market crash, causing USDT holders to flee en masse. If Tether’s reserves, for whatever reason, could not be liquidated quickly enough (imagine a scenario where U.S. Treasuries markets are closed or extremely illiquid, or a major portion of reserves is impaired), USDT’s price could free-fall. Even a temporary failure of USDT would likely cause chaos in crypto markets – prices of bitcoin and others might plummet as traders lose their primary stable unit, and other stablecoins could also come under redemption pressure (a contagion effect). This systemic risk is why analysts say Tether is “too big to fail” for crypto. CoinShares’ Butterfill pointed out that if Tether failed, it’d trigger a dramatic decline in trading volumes and liquidity across the ecosystem (Tether's $100 billion stokes stablecoin stability concerns | Reuters). This could be akin to a Lehman Brothers moment for crypto. Now, how likely is such a collapse? It’s hard to quantify – Tether has withstood many past crises and in 2023/24 began accumulating profits (over $5B in 2024 H1) as a buffer (Tether (cryptocurrency) - Wikipedia). Those profits (largely from interest on its Treasury holdings) actually strengthen Tether’s balance sheet, arguably making it more robust over time, with over-collateralization (roughly 105% reserves) reported (Tether (cryptocurrency) - Wikipedia). However, skeptics note that until a full audit is seen, one can’t be fully assured of no hidden holes.

Another risk is competition from central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) or more regulated stablecoins which could erode Tether’s dominance in the future – but that’s more of a long-term competitive risk than an immediate danger. If, say, a U.S. digital dollar or a regulated EU stablecoin became available and widely adopted, users might prefer those to USDT, shrinking Tether’s relevance. Tether would then face business challenges, though it could also incorporate those or adjust.

To sum up the risk factors: Tether carries significant issuer risk. Unlike holding cash in a insured bank account or holding a fully regulated money market fund, holding USDT means trusting a private company operating in a lightly regulated context. The past has shown instances of misleading claims and opaque operations, which Tether has been penalized for (Attorney General James Ends Virtual Currency Trading Platform Bitfinex’s Illegal Activities in New York) (Cryptocurrency Tether is fined $41 million for lying about reserves). While improvements have been made (greater disclosure, reserve de-risking), the absence of comprehensive transparency means an investor must be comfortable with that trust leap. There is also regulatory event risk – sudden legal changes could impact USDT’s usability. And finally, there’s a tail-risk of a peg break in extreme scenarios, which would likely coincide with broader market turmoil.

As an investor or trader using USDT, it’s prudent to approach it with a risk-managed mindset. In the next sections, we’ll discuss the opportunities that could further strengthen Tether’s position (and perhaps mitigate some risks), and strategies to use USDT while managing the risks outlined here.

‍

4. Opportunities

Despite the risks, Tether’s future is also ripe with opportunities for growth and innovation. Several macro trends and strategic avenues could bolster USDT’s utility and adoption in the coming years. For investors, understanding these potential tailwinds and expansion areas provides context for Tether’s long-term outlook.

Expansion in Emerging Markets and Global Finance: Perhaps the most promising opportunity for Tether is to capitalize on its role as a dollar substitute in emerging markets. We have already seen how USDT usage has surged in countries with economic instability – this trend is likely to continue or even accelerate. High inflation and currency crises in various regions create a natural demand for stable USD-denominated assets. Tether can expand outreach and on-ramps in such markets, effectively becoming the digital dollar of choice for millions of unbanked or underbanked users. Paolo Ardoino, Tether’s CEO, noted that USDT’s recent growth has been driven not just by crypto trading, but by use as an alternative to USD in emerging economies (Stablecoin Tether gets boost as dollar alternative in emerging markets, CEO says | Reuters) (Stablecoin Tether gets boost as dollar alternative in emerging markets, CEO says | Reuters). He mentioned countries like Turkey (which saw >80% inflation), Argentina (with strict capital controls and inflation over 100%), Vietnam, Brazil, and various African nations where dollars are in short supply (Stablecoin Tether gets boost as dollar alternative in emerging markets, CEO says | Reuters). In these environments, USDT can further embed itself in everyday transactions – e.g. local merchants accepting USDT via mobile apps, remittance corridors fully running on Tether, or even salaries being paid partly in stablecoins. Every additional real-world integration (such as a payment processor or fintech app adding USDT support) grows Tether’s reach. There’s also an opportunity for Tether to partner with fintech and money service businesses in emerging markets, bridging crypto with traditional cash networks. For instance, integrating USDT with mobile money platforms or ATM networks in countries like Nigeria or Argentina could allow easy swapping between cash and USDT, thus widening usage. Being “the dollar for the last mile” not only serves a huge social need but also cements USDT’s relevance if it becomes ingrained in local financial systems (Stablecoin Tether gets boost as dollar alternative in emerging markets, CEO says | Reuters).

Growing Role in Remittances and International Settlement: Closely related is the remittance market. Global remittances are a ~$500 billion annual flow traditionally dominated by firms like Western Union, which charge hefty fees. Stablecoins are already disrupting this: people are finding it cheaper to send USDT across borders and have recipients convert it to local currency via peer-to-peer exchanges. Tether has an opportunity to make USDT a standard settlement currency for remittances. If Tether can form alliances with remittance providers or aid in building corridors (e.g. USDT flow from Middle East to South Asia, or from Europe/US to Africa), it can capture a slice of this huge market. A case study is Latin America, where crypto usage for remittances is rising – Venezuelans or Mexicans working abroad have used USDT to send money home faster and cheaper than traditional means. As stablecoins gain regulatory clarity, even traditional financial institutions might start leveraging them for cross-border settlements to avoid slow wire transfers. Tether, being the largest stablecoin, could be a beneficiary if, say, a regional bank or payment company chooses to route funds through USDT for efficiency. Each such use increases legitimate demand for USDT in day-to-day commerce, potentially reducing its reliance on speculative crypto trading demand.

Integration with Decentralized Finance and Web3 Innovations: On the technological front, Tether stands to gain from the continuing expansion of DeFi and Web3 applications. Stablecoins are the lifeblood of DeFi, and as new protocols and blockchain networks emerge, Tether can extend USDT to those ecosystems. For example, if new layer-1 or layer-2 blockchains gain traction (like how Tron did for cheap USDT transfers, or how new rollups and sidechains are appearing), Tether can quickly deploy USDT there, capturing early liquidity. Interoperability upgrades like permissionless bridges or Tether issuing “omnichain” tokens could make USDT even more fluid across networks, enhancing its utility (imagine moving USDT between Ethereum, Solana, and Arbitrum seamlessly – technologies like CCIP or LayerZero might help enable such scenarios, and Tether can adopt them). Moreover, as DeFi matures, more institutions may enter DeFi and require stablecoins as collateral or for transactions. USDT, if it maintains its dominance, would likely see increased demand from institutional DeFi use (e.g. crypto funds using USDT to provide liquidity or trade on decentralized exchanges, etc.).

Tether is also exploring financial innovations beyond just USD stablecoins. It launched Tether Gold (XAU₮), a token backed by physical gold, catering to investors who want digital gold exposure (Tether Eliminates Commercial Paper From Reserves in ... - Decrypt). XAU₮ has grown modestly, and if interest in tokenized commodities rises, Tether could expand offerings (they could consider other commodities or currency-pegged tokens; a digital euro tether (EUR₮) exists, though small compared to USDT). Additionally, Tether’s substantial profits from reserves (due to high interest rates, Tether reportedly earned $1.5B+ profit in one quarter of 2023 and $5B in half-year 2024 (Tether (cryptocurrency) - Wikipedia)) give it capital to invest in new ventures. Notably, Tether has announced moves into Bitcoin mining and renewable energy – for example, investing in sustainable Bitcoin mining facilities in Uruguay and El Salvador (Stablecoin giant Tether to mine bitcoin in Uruguay using renewables) (Stablecoin Issuer Tether Invests in Sustainable Bitcoin Mining in ...). While not directly related to USDT, these investments could diversify Tether’s business and potentially integrate with stablecoin operations (imagine Tether mining bitcoin to bolster reserves or using excess energy capacity to stabilize grids via crypto – speculative but interesting). If these ventures succeed, Tether’s financial strength grows, indirectly shoring up confidence in USDT.

‍

Thank you for taking the time to read this article. We invite you to explore more content on our blog for additional insights and information.

https://www.thestandard.io/blog  

‍

"If you have any comments, questions, or suggestions, please do not hesitate to reach out to us at [Email “Coming Soon”]. We appreciate your feedback and look forward to hearing from you."

‍

CLICK HERE TO CONTINUE

PAGE 4: www.thestandard.io/blog/tether-usdt-investment-analysis---a-comprehensive-report-4